1 John 5:7-8 Comma Johanneum – Trinity College MS 52, Dublin, or the “Book of Armagh” (circa. 9th century C.E.)

Liber Ardmachanus, or Book of Armagh, or Codex Dublinensis. Copied in Ireland, probably Armagh, in 807/8. Written in (what I think is quite beautiful personally) Irish minuscule script.

Images Online: http://digitalcollections.tcd.ie/home/#folder_id=26&pidtopage=MS52_01&entry_point=1

Folio 155, 1 John begins: https://digitalcollections.tcd.ie/home/#folder_id=1827&pidtopage=MS52_001&entry_point=319

Folio 156 [157v], 1 John 5:7-8: https://digitalcollections.tcd.ie/home/#folder_id=1827&pidtopage=MS52_001&entry_point=322

Now there was a claim by Irish Clergyman in the 19th Century, that this manuscript contained part/parts (“traces”) of the “Comma Johanneum” reading in the below publication:

Irish Ecclesiastical Record – Vol 5 – 1869
Traces of the Text of the Three Heavenly Witnesses
Abbe (Arthur Marie) le Hir (1811-1868)
http://archive.org/stream/irishecclesiasti05dubluoft#page/266/mode/2up
p. 266-277

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 4a ) Folio 156

Page 266 article begins:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 4b ) Folio 156

Page 276 specific claim is made:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 4c ) Folio 156

Enlarged image of the text:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 4d ) Folio 156

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 4e ) Folio 156

The claim is that that this manuscript contained part/parts (“traces”) of the “Comma Johanneum” reading, either:

  1. “in terra”
  2. “in coelo”

Are either of these readings in the manuscript? Have a look for yourself!

Beginning of 1st John:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 2 )

Enlarged image of the script:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 2a )

Folio 157, the text of 1st John 5:7-8 etc.

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 3 ) Folio 156

Same, slightly more enlarged:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 3a ) Folio 156

Zoomed in on the text:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 3b ) Folio 156

Same again:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 3c ) Folio 156

The claim beside the text:

Dublin, Trinity College MS. 52 ( 4 ) Folio 156

There is no trace of either:

  1. “in terra”
  2. “in coelo”

In the Latin text at all. It is a Vulgate text here, with Jerome’s signature: “Christus est veritas” (abbreviated in the MS).

There is no trace of the Comma Johanneum in this manuscript at 1st John 5:7-8 (either in the text or in the margin).

Leave a comment